Blog > when not to hire


A Hiring manager failing a tech candidate during an virtual interview while being evaluated for a software engineering position despite strong technical skills.

The Brilliant Candidate Nobody Wanted to Hire: When Interview Performance and Job Performance Collide

**Excerpt:** A candidate arrives late, ignores interview preparation instructions, struggles with their technical setup, and leaves a poor first impression. Most hiring managers would reject them immediately. But what if they are the most qualified candidate for the role? Discover how leading companies separate interview performance from job performance, avoid costly hiring mistakes, and identify when a bad interview should not outweigh exceptional technical skills. Learn the key factors every recruiter and hiring manager should consider before rejecting a great engineer after a poor interview experience.

Posted by Kat Stam | May 20, 2026